In a US store, muskmelon and cantaloupe are usually the same melon: the round one with raised tan netting and orange flesh.
- "Muskmelon" is the wider group name for this kind of melon.
- The true cantaloupe is a ribbed, warty European melon with little or no netting.
Grocers, gardeners and botanists each use a different word for these melons, a pattern that shows up in many comparisons of look-alike foods. If your recipe says muskmelon and the sign at the store says cantaloupe, you can buy the cantaloupe.
1. What Is the Difference Between Muskmelon and Cantaloupe?
All of these melons belong to one species, Cucumis melo, so the differences come from the group inside the species. Watermelon is a cousin from another genus, Citrullus, so it is not a muskmelon, and its mild, watery flavor sets it apart. Three melons come up most often, and the rind is the quickest way to tell them apart.
| Trait | Muskmelon (US "cantaloupe") | European cantaloupe | Honeydew |
|---|---|---|---|
| Botanical group | Reticulatus, the netted melons | Cantalupensis | Inodorus, the winter melons |
| Rind | Raised tan netting over green-gray skin | Ribbed and warty, with little or no netting | Smooth and hard |
| Leaves the vine | Slips off the vine when ripe | Often does not slip when mature | Hard rind, keeps well |
| Examples | The cantaloupe in a US produce aisle | Charentais, Prescott, D'Alger | Honeydew, casaba, Crenshaw |
The rind tells you more than the name does. If it is covered in netting, you are holding the American type, ribs and warts point to the European one, and a smooth hard rind means a winter melon such as honeydew.
2. Why Do Americans Call a Muskmelon a Cantaloupe?
Britannica defines muskmelon as any of several netted-rind melons with sweet, musky orange flesh, and it notes that North Americans sometimes call them cantaloupes. Strictly, it reserves the name cantaloupe for the European Cantalupensis group.
Sources do not use "muskmelon" the same way. Britannica means the netted melons only, while the old saying "every cantaloupe is a muskmelon, but not every muskmelon is a cantaloupe" only works if you stretch muskmelon to cover the whole species, honeydew included. Which word you hear depends mostly on where you are:
- In a US grocery store, the sign says cantaloupe and the fruit is a netted muskmelon.
- In Europe, a cantaloupe is the ribbed type. Missouri Extension names Charentais, Prescott, D'Alger and Petit gris de Rennes among the true cantaloupes grown there.
- In a recipe that says muskmelon, the author almost always means the orange, netted melon that US stores sell as cantaloupe.
3. Do Muskmelon and Cantaloupe Taste Different?
If you shop in the US, you are comparing a fruit with itself, so a "muskmelon" and a "cantaloupe" taste the same when they are equally ripe. What changes the flavor is how ripe the melon was when it was picked. UC Davis Postharvest says growers pick cantaloupe at three-quarter to full slip, when the fruit separates from the vine under light pressure, and it counts raised, well-rounded netting as another sign of maturity.
You can read the same signs at the store, in this order:
- Look at the stem end. A smooth, round dent where the vine let go means a full slip. A jagged scar or a bit of stem left on means the melon came off early.
- Check the netting. It should be raised and well formed over the whole rind.
- Lift it. A ripe melon feels heavy for its size.
- Smell the stem end. A sweet, musky smell means it is ready. If you smell nothing, wait a few days on the counter.
- Press the blossom end. A little give is right, and a soft or mushy spot means skip it.
A ribbed European cantaloupe is trickier. Missouri Extension says it often does not slip from the vine, so the stem-scar test tells you less and you will rely on smell, weight and the color between the ribs.
4. How Do the Nutrition Numbers Compare?
USDA FoodData Central lists a raw "cantaloupe," which in the US means the netted type. Next to honeydew, the other melon people compare it with, the numbers per 100 grams look like this:
| Per 100 g, raw | Cantaloupe (netted muskmelon) | Honeydew |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 34 kcal | 36 kcal |
| Water | 90.2 g | 89.8 g |
| Total sugars | 7.86 g | 8.12 g |
| Fiber | 0.9 g | 0.8 g |
| Vitamin C | 36.7 mg | 18.0 mg |
| Vitamin A (RAE) | 169 µg | 3 µg |
| Beta-carotene | 2,020 µg | 30 µg |
| Potassium | 267 mg | 228 mg |
Calories, water and fiber are nearly the same, so the real gap is in the orange pigment. Cantaloupe has about 56 times the vitamin A of honeydew because beta-carotene gives the flesh its color, and it also has twice the vitamin C. Muskmelon and cantaloupe do not differ in calories or water, because in the US they are the same fruit, and honeydew sits only 2 kcal higher.
5. Do You Need to Wash the Rind Before Cutting?
Yes, and the netted muskmelon is the melon where it matters most. Health Canada says bacteria from the outer rind can move into the flesh when your knife goes through, and that cantaloupe carries more risk because of its netted rind. The FDA gives the same instruction for all melons in its produce safety advice: scrub firm produce, such as melons, with a clean produce brush.
The 2011 Listeria outbreak shows what is at stake. The CDC linked it to whole cantaloupes from Jensen Farms in Granada, Colorado, and reported 147 infected people in 28 states and 33 deaths. The CDC also warned that the bacteria can keep growing in cantaloupe at room and refrigerator temperatures, so if a recall names your melon, you throw out the whole fruit.
Here is the routine from those sources, in the order you do it:
- Scrub the whole melon. Use cool running water and a clean produce brush, working into the netting.
- Dry it. A clean cloth or paper towel works, as the FDA suggests.
- Cut with a clean knife and board. The blade is what carries rind bacteria into the flesh.
- Chill the cut pieces. Keep them in a covered container in a fridge at 40°F or below and eat cut cantaloupe within four days, which is Health Canada's limit.
- Discard anything left out too long. Cut melon that sat at room temperature for more than two hours goes in the trash, sooner if the room was warm.
6. Can You Use Muskmelon Instead of Cantaloupe?
In the US you can swap them cup for cup, because they are the same fruit. A ribbed European cantaloupe also works in the same amount of cubes or puree, but taste a piece first, since its sweetness depends on how ripe it is.
When you cannot find a ripe orange melon, honeydew is the closest stand-in, and Persian or casaba melon also fill the role in fruit salad, smoothies and chilled soup. Your dish will turn pale green, and you lose most of the vitamin A, since honeydew has 3 µg per 100 g against 169 µg in cantaloupe. Ripe cubes of either melon also blend into fruit smoothies.
7. Which One Should You Buy?
Pick by what you plan to do with the melon:
- Your recipe says muskmelon or cantaloupe and you shop in the US: buy the netted orange cantaloupe, since both names point to it. Choose one with a smooth stem scar and a sweet smell.
- You want the most vitamin A and vitamin C from the fruit: the orange cantaloupe wins, with 169 µg vitamin A and 36.7 mg vitamin C per 100 g against 3 µg and 18 mg in honeydew.
- You want pale green cubes next to orange ones in a fruit salad: add honeydew, which has nearly the same calories and water.
- You find a ribbed melon labeled Charentais at a specialty market: treat it as a different melon, the true cantaloupe, and judge ripeness by smell and weight because it may not slip from the vine.
Sources
- Britannica, Muskmelon
- University of Missouri Extension, High Tunnel Melon and Watermelon Production (M173)
- UC Davis Postharvest Technology Center, Cantaloupe: Maturity and Quality
- USDA FoodData Central, Melons, cantaloupe, raw (FDC 169092) and Melons, honeydew, raw (FDC 169911)
- FDA, Selecting and Serving Produce Safely
- Health Canada, Food Safety Tips for Melons
- CDC, 2011 Outbreak of Listeria Infections Linked to Whole Cantaloupes from Jensen Farms, Colorado

Food writer and recipe developer. Restaurant industry veteran sharing real recipes, honest substitutes, and tips that actually work in a home kitchen.




