Picanha is the top sirloin cap, so it is a top sirloin cut, but the fattier one.
- Picanha is a triangular muscle over the main top sirloin muscle, sold with its fat cap on.
- A top sirloin steak comes from the meat under the cap and has only a thin fat edge.
- Cook picanha as a roast or thick steaks.
When you line up beef cuts side by side, picanha is the one with the most names. The same muscle is called coulotte, rump cap and top sirloin cap depending on the package, the country and the butcher, and that is why a search for "is picanha top sirloin" turns up so many half answers.
1. Is Picanha the Same as Top Sirloin?
Picanha comes from the top sirloin butt, but it is not the same piece of meat as a top sirloin steak. Butchers separate the cap from the larger muscle under it, so you will find the two sold and cooked differently.
Picanha is the cap of the top sirloin butt, where the loin meets the round. A top sirloin steak comes from the main body of the top sirloin butt, directly under the cap.
| Trait | Picanha (top sirloin cap) | Top sirloin steak |
|---|---|---|
| Muscle | One muscle, the biceps femoris | Often more than one muscle in a single steak |
| Fat | A thick fat cap, up to about an inch before trimming | A thin fat edge |
| Shape and size | A triangle, usually 2 to 3 lb whole | Flat boneless steaks |
- You buy it whole, as a roast, or cut into thick steaks, often by request at the butcher counter.
- Cook it on the grill, rotisserie or oven roast, fat side down first.
- It comes as packaged steaks labeled top sirloin.
- Cook it on the grill, skillet, broiler or kabobs.
The fat cap is the difference that changes your dinner, because it melts over the meat while you cook picanha, and a top sirloin steak has nothing like it. Coulotte steaks are cut from this same cap, so when a package says "coulotte" or "top sirloin cap" you are buying the same muscle as picanha, often with less of the fat left on.
2. Are Picanha and Top Sirloin Cap the Same Thing?
Yes, they are one muscle with several names, and the name you see depends on who cut it and where:
- Picanha is the Brazilian name, and it usually means the cap sold with its fat layer on.
- Coulotte or culotte is the name on many US packages. The Beef Checkoff's retail chart lists it as Coulotte Steak, also called Top Sirloin Cap Steak, Boneless (IMPS/NAMP 1184D).
- Rump cap or rump cover is the British and older butcher name. The UK's AHDB specification calls it "Rump Cap (picanha)" and trims the outside fat to 10 mm at most.
Beef is first divided into big sections called primals. The sirloin primal sits behind the short loin and ahead of the round, and butchers split it into the top sirloin butt and the bottom sirloin butt, which is why top and bottom sirloin steaks are sold so differently. Picanha belongs to the top half.
Texas A&M Animal Science notes that the muscle fibers in the center of a top sirloin run in a different direction than the cap's, which is why shops take the two apart and sell them as separate cuts.
3. How Do Fat and Tenderness Compare?
Picanha bastes itself while you cook it. The cap can be an inch thick before trimming, according to Crowd Cow's cut guide, and the Beef Checkoff describes coulotte steak as well marbled and juicy.
A top sirloin steak is lean by comparison. USDA data on the Checkoff's site puts a 3 oz cooked serving of trimmed top sirloin steak at about 150 calories and 4.9 g of fat. We found no published figure for picanha as sold, because how much cap you leave on or trim off changes the total.
Tenderness depends on the muscle. A 2023 study in Meat and Muscle Biology profiled the muscles that make up the top sirloin butt, the biceps femoris among them, and found they differ in tenderness, so you may find one top sirloin steak chews a little differently from the next. Picanha is a single muscle, which means each piece has one grain direction. That grain decides how you slice it:
4. How Do You Cook Picanha Versus Top Sirloin Steak?
Both cuts do well over high heat, but the cap changes the order of steps:
- Score the fat in a tight diamond pattern
- Salt it coarsely, then cook fat side down over indirect heat
- Rest it about 10 minutes and slice across the grain
- Season it with salt and pepper or a dry rub
- Cook it hot and fast on the grill, skillet or broiler
- Watch the thermometer, because lean steak dries out fast
Stop scoring before you reach the meat, and salt picanha about 40 minutes ahead or as it goes on the fire. To finish, move it over direct heat to crisp the cap, or roast it fat side down in a 450°F oven as the Beef Checkoff's picanha recipe does. The Beef Checkoff suggests the same simple salt and pepper or dry rub for top sirloin, which also cuts into cubes for kabobs.
5. Is Picanha the Same as Striploin, Tri-Tip or Sirloin Tip?
You will run into three other names in the same searches, and none of them is picanha:
- Striploin is the strip steak, from the short loin in front of the sirloin. It is a different part of the animal, and a strip steak or New York strip is sold as an individual steak.
- Tri-tip comes from the bottom sirloin butt, the other half of the sirloin, and it has no cap. Texas A&M lists ball tip, tri-tip and flap as the bottom sirloin cuts, and a tri-tip roast is sliced much like picanha.
- Sirloin tip is cut from the round, the back leg, so despite the name it is not a sirloin cut at all. The sirloin tip roast is leaner and eats differently from either of the cuts on this page.
6. Can You Use Top Sirloin Instead of Picanha?
Yes in a pinch, and it works better in one direction than the other:
- Works for grilled steaks and kabobs, seasoned the same way
- Has no fat cap, so skip scoring and the fat-side-down step
- Cooks faster, so go by the thermometer
- Ask the butcher for coulotte steaks cut 1 to 2 inches thick
- Cap fat flares on a grill, so keep a cooler zone
- Needs no marinade, since the cap bastes it
Most picanha recipes serve chimichurri beside it, and the same sauce suits top sirloin. Skip picanha when you want the lean profile of a trimmed top sirloin.
Ball tip, a bottom sirloin cut, is a leaner stand-in that needs a marinade and thin slices, and ball tip next to tri-tip shows how those two differ. If the store has neither, steaks that replace top sirloin cover most recipes.
7. Which One Should You Buy?
Match the cut to the meal:
- A weekend cookout for a crowd: a whole picanha or coulotte roast, grilled or roasted fat side down and sliced across the grain. The Beef Checkoff lists coulotte roast as best roasted in the oven or smoked slowly on the grill.
- A weeknight steak in a skillet: top sirloin steaks, which cook in minutes and need only salt and pepper.
- Kabobs: top sirloin cubes, since the Beef Checkoff lists top sirloin steak for cutting into kabobs.
- A leaner plate: top sirloin, or picanha with most of the cap trimmed off before you eat it.
These buying signals save you a second trip:
- Look for the names picanha, coulotte or top sirloin cap. A label that says only "sirloin steak" can be any sirloin cut, and the cap usually has to be asked for at the counter.
- Leave at least a quarter inch of fat on a picanha. Crowd Cow advises that much cap so it can baste the meat as it cooks.
- Remember you pay by the pound for the fat. Part of the cap renders away or gets trimmed, so a picanha yields less cooked meat per pound than a top sirloin steak. Prices change by store and region, so compare the tags.
For the plate, sides for picanha lean toward farofa, rice and bright salads, and sides for a sirloin steak suit a skillet dinner. A spoonful of chimichurri sauce works with both cuts.
Sources
- American Foods Group, Coulotte Steak: Beef Checkoff retail chart entry, IMPS/NAMP 1184D, other names, top sirloin butt and bottom sirloin butt, "well marbled, juicy and savory."
- American Foods Group, Sirloin Primal: top sirloin steak, coulotte steak and coulotte roast, with Beef Checkoff cooking notes.
- Texas A&M Animal Science, sirloin cuts: cap and center-cut fibers run differently; ball tip, tri-tip and flap come from the bottom sirloin.
- Crowd Cow, Picanha: biceps femoris, fat cap up to an inch thick, 2 to 3 lb piece, slicing across the grain, quarter inch of cap to leave on (retailer guide, not an official source).
- AHDB, Rump Cap (picanha): UK butcher specification for the cap, with external fat trimmed to 10 mm.
- Beef. It's What's For Dinner, Roasted Picanha Puttanesca: picanha as sirloin cap or coulotte, scored fat, 450°F oven.
- Meat and Muscle Biology, Muscle Profiling of the Biceps Femoris, Gluteus Accessorius, and Gluteus Medius Comprising the Beef Top Sirloin Butt: muscle-to-muscle tenderness variation.
- USDA FSIS, Safe Minimum Internal Temperature Chart: 145°F with a 3-minute rest for beef steaks and roasts.

Food writer at GustoMeadow. Writes ingredient substitutes, food comparisons, taste guides and storage guides for home cooks.
Storage and food-safety numbers follow USDA, FDA and university extension guidance.






