Both brands sell a summer sausage and cheese gift, so choose by the extras: Swiss Colony for bakery gifts and sugar-free sweets, and Hickory Farms for a turkey sausage, a delivery date you pick and holiday stores.
- Swiss Colony began in 1926 in Monroe, Wisconsin, and Hickory Farms in 1951.
- Swiss Colony says to refrigerate its summer sausage even before you open it.
Both companies are US gift-food brands, so this page, like the other head-to-head food comparisons on the site, looks at what ends up in the box and how it reaches the person you are sending it to. The picks below rest on each company's own pages and on USDA storage guidance.
1. What Is the Difference Between Swiss Colony and Hickory Farms?
Both brands started with cheese, but they now sell it in different ways, as you can see on each company's own site:
| Trait | Swiss Colony | Hickory Farms |
|---|---|---|
| Started | 1926, as a mail-order cheese business by Ray Kubly in Monroe, Wisconsin | 1951, by Richard Ransom, who sold hand-crafted cheese at fairs and farmers markets |
| Delivery | Expedited (usually 3 to 5 business days) or Express (usually 1 to 2) | You choose the delivery date at checkout |
The sausage and cheese shelf is where the two catalogs overlap most:
- Beef Log, an all-beef summer sausage, plus garlic and caraway sausages in samplers
- Cheese bars and spreads, with Monterey Jack, cheddar, Colby and brick in samplers
- Beef, turkey and Farmhouse summer sausages, plus dry salami
- Cheeses, cheese balls and cheese spreads
Two more differences show up in what else is on offer and in how you order:
- Sweets and bakery. Swiss Colony lists petits fours and bakery gifts as their own category, and Hickory Farms lists mints, nuts, peanut brittle and cupcakes.
- How you buy. Swiss Colony sells through its website to the USA, US territories and APO/FPO addresses only, and Hickory Farms adds a delivery date you choose plus local stores in the holiday season.
Both companies sell the same core gift, a box of summer sausage and cheese. The gap is in what surrounds it: Swiss Colony adds a bakery shelf, and Hickory Farms adds a turkey sausage, snacks and stores you can walk into.
2. How Did Each Company Start?
Swiss Colony: Cheese First, Then a Bakery
Swiss Colony began in 1926 in Monroe, Wisconsin, when Ray Kubly, a recent University of Wisconsin-Madison graduate, started mailing Wisconsin cheese from his family home's basement. His first mailing offered cuts of Wisconsin-made bulk cheeses for the holidays, and UW-Madison's history of the firm adds that it sold 50 packages of cheese in its first year.
- 1954: Kubly incorporated the business.
- 1959: The company opened its own bakery, and its first product was the Dobosh Torte, a Hungarian layer cake.
- 1961: Horst Hart hand-dipped petits fours, first made for a family party, and they joined the catalog.
Cheese came first and the bakery came 33 years later, so Swiss Colony sells both as separate shelves.
Hickory Farms: Fairs, Then Stores
Hickory Farms began in 1951, when Richard Ransom started selling hand-crafted cheese at local fairs and farmers markets. Its About page dates the rest of its story to a handful of years:
- 1956: its original Beef Stick debuted and later became its award-winning summer sausage.
- 1959: the first retail store opened in Toledo, Ohio.
- 1971: it reported selling 1 million jars of mustard.
- 1981: it reported over 1,000 stores and seasonal kiosks in the US and Canada.
- 2021: it bought Wicked Good Cupcakes.
The store count is much smaller now. Hickory Farms' FAQ says its local stores generally open only in the holiday season and that locations may be fewer this year, so use its store locator before you plan a visit.
Nothing on either company's pages says one owns the other. Swiss Colony's heritage page names the Kubly family as the owner of Swiss Colony and Colony Brands, and the Hickory Farms About page names no owner.
3. What Do They Sell Besides Sausage and Cheese?
The extras decide whether the box you send feels like a ready-made snack board or a mixed gift. These lists come from each brand's own menus and About page:
- Petits fours and bakery gifts as a separate shopping category
- Sausages, sticks and beef logs
- Meat and cheese assortments
- Gift baskets and boxes, including a "Delivery Included" category
- Crackers, mustard and condiments next to the meats and cheeses
- Mints, nuts, peanut brittle and other sweets
- Wine gifts and the Deluxe Signature Charcuterie Gift Box
- Cupcakes, added when it bought Wicked Good Cupcakes in 2021
If the person you are buying for likes cake more than cured meat, Swiss Colony's bakery category gives you something to send that a sausage-focused catalog does not. The Hickory Farms menu lists crackers, mustard and wine gifts, which are the items you would otherwise buy separately to turn a box of meat and cheese into a board.
Swiss Colony's menu goes well beyond food: it also lists personalized gifts, home and kitchen goods, apparel, jewelry and electronics. Hickory Farms' About page lists gift boxes, wine gifts, advent calendars and corporate gifts, and it offers free shipping on its collection of military gifts.
Sugar-Free and Gluten-Free Gifts
Swiss Colony runs a Sugar-Free & Gluten-Free category. On November 17, 2026 it listed 24 items, 20 marked sugar free and one marked gluten free, a raspberry linzer cookie.
- Sugar-free petits fours, chocolate pecan fudge and brownie bars
- Sugar-free almond brittle, peppermint patties and dipped pretzels
- A no-sugar-added fruitcake ring and trail mix
Hickory Farms' FAQ says it offers meat-free and select gluten-free gifts. It also has a gluten-free gift category, and the label appears on individual product pages. The Cheese & Sausage Lover's Gift Box page says "This product is gluten free" and lists milk as its allergen.
4. How Do the Sausage and Cheese Gifts Compare?
Summer Sausage
Hickory Farms gives you three summer sausages to choose from: beef, turkey and Farmhouse. If the recipient does not eat beef, the turkey one is the place to start, and its About page describes Farmhouse as a beef and pork blend, so skip that one for anyone who avoids pork.
Its flagship is the Signature Beef Summer Sausage, which the company says is made with 100% premium North American beef. The 7 oz size comes in 4 or 8 packs, and Hickory Farms sells a dry salami, too.
Swiss Colony's sausage is its Beef Log, which its blog says was renamed from all-beef summer sausage by 1969. Its product page says each batch is hardwood-smoked, and the log comes in 1, 2 and 3 lb sizes.
Swiss Colony's meat shelf is wider than the log alone. Its Meats & Cheeses category also lists:
- Wild game meat sticks in buffalo, elk and venison
- Jumbo one-pound sausage and cheese bars
- A spiral sliced ham and a hickory-smoked whole turkey
Summer sausage is a tangy, semi-dry sausage, and Swiss Colony says it gets that tang from lactic acid fermentation rather than citric acid.
Cheese
Swiss Colony's sampler pages show how its boxes grow. The gift of 4 holds Monterey Jack and cheddar plus original and garlic summer sausage, the gift of 6 adds Colby and caraway summer sausage, and the gift of 8 adds two brick cheeses and a second garlic sausage.
Cheddar is sold in strengths, and mild and medium cheddar taste different enough that a box listing only "cheddar" is worth a second look at the product page.
Hickory Farms names its cheeses as blends, such as Sharp Cheddar Blend, Jalapeño Cheddar Blend and Smoked Gouda Blend, and its Cheese & Sausage Lover's Gift Box holds five of them at 4 oz each.
Spreads, Mustard and Crackers
Hickory Farms lists cheese balls and spreads next to its block cheese, which gives you something to spread on the crackers. Mustard is its other long-running product: its About page calls the Sweet Hot Mustard a cornerstone, and its Sunny Summer Sausage & Cheese Gift Box adds a 2.5 oz Honey Pineapple Mustard.
Swiss Colony sells Incredible Spreadables as a pick-and-choose set and as a sampler, including a set with crunchy crackers, so spreads are part of its range too.
5. How Do Price and Value Compare?
Prices change with every sale, so this section gives you a dated snapshot from the companies' own product pages on November 17, 2026, and it shows how to compare any two boxes.
- Swiss Colony: The Original Beef Log in 1, 2 and 3 lb sizes, listed at $19.99 to $39.99 under a Cyber Sale banner.
- Hickory Farms: 7 oz Signature Beef Summer Sausage in 4 or 8 packs, listed at $28.99 to $57.99 and showing out of stock that day.
- Hickory Farms box: the Cheese & Sausage Lover's Gift Box at $65.99 for 3.00 lb.
The two companies use different units: Swiss Colony's Beef Log page lists pounds, and Hickory Farms' pages list ounces for each sausage and cheese. Convert one to the other before you compare.
The total changes with shipping, and the two sites handle it differently:
- Swiss Colony's Delivery Included category says each price already includes discounted shipping and processing for one gift to one address. Gifts shipped outside the 48 states go by air for an added $14.99 on top of the standard charges.
- Swiss Colony frozen items ship in an insulated cooler with dry ice for $9.99 per address, and frozen and non-frozen items can arrive a few days apart.
- Swiss Colony delivery fees on its shipping page are $12.99 per address for Expedited and $24.99 for Express, plus $3.99 for each extra address.
- Hickory Farms marks some boxes "Free Shipping on Select Gifts", with limits listed in the footnote, and ships its collection of military gifts free.
Compare the final total with delivery for the exact box you want, because a sale price on one site can disappear after the shipping line is added.
6. How Do Delivery and Customer Service Compare?
Both companies ship food that has to survive a trip, and each one says how it handles that.
- Packing: Hickory Farms says it uses insulated packaging and cold packs to keep perishable items fresh in transit.
- Delivery days: it does not ship some perishable products over the weekend, so Monday delivery is not always available.
- Freshness: its Freshness Guarantee promises that gourmet holiday gifts arrive fresh and ready to eat, or it will make it right.
- Guarantee: Hickory Farms' policy is "100% Satisfaction Guaranteed", and you call or email for a replacement, refund or credit, whichever you prefer.
- Out of stock: a gift recipient gets a similar item of equal or greater value, and sausages and salami are never substituted.
- Best-by date: its sausage page guarantees at least 45 days before the printed best-by date when the box arrives.
Swiss Colony's paid delivery options are Expedited, usually 3 to 5 business days, and Express, usually 1 to 2 business days when you order by 11:00 p.m. Central Time. Frozen gifts need a street address and a daytime phone number.
Its site also links to Our Guarantee, Shipping Information and Holiday Deadlines pages, so read the holiday deadline for your order before you pay.
7. Where Can You Buy Each One?
Both brands sell through their own websites, and the differences show up at checkout:
- Swiss Colony accepts orders from and ships to the USA, US territories, and APO and FPO addresses only. Its checkout also lets you send gifts to several addresses at $3.99 for each extra address.
- Hickory Farms lets you shop year-round online and choose your delivery date at checkout. It also offers in-store pickup and runs local stores during the holiday season. Pick Ship to Multiple Addresses at its Shipping step.
8. How Should You Store a Meat and Cheese Gift?
Swiss Colony's blog says summer sausage does need refrigeration, particularly after opening, and it adds "Refrigerate after opening, of course, but also before opening." The same blog allows an opened log up to a month.
The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service lists summer sausage labeled "Keep Refrigerated" at 3 months unopened and 3 weeks after opening in the fridge. Use the shorter 3 weeks for a gift you are sharing, and follow the package label if it says something different.
Hickory Farms' FAQ calls its summer sausage shelf-stable and recommends refrigerating it to keep it fresh for longer. Both brands end up at the same habit, so this is the order to follow when a gift arrives:
- Check the labels. Look for each item's date and any storage line printed on it.
- Refrigerate the meat and cheese. Put summer sausage and all cheese on a fridge shelf, unless the label says shelf-stable.
- Rewrap cut ends. Press plastic wrap against the cut face of the sausage and cheese, then write the date you opened it on the wrap.
- Finish the sausage within 3 weeks. That is the FSIS figure for an opened summer sausage, and our summer sausage storage times cover freezing and spoilage signs.
- Keep crackers in the pantry. FoodKeeper lists 8 months unopened and about 1 month once the package is open.
9. Is Either Brand Good Quality?
This section sticks to what each company states and what you can check on a product page.
- Hickory Farms says its Signature Beef Summer Sausage uses 100% premium North American beef and has held the American Masters of Taste Gold Medal since 2011.
- Swiss Colony says its Beef Log starts with the finest beef and a blend of spices, and that each batch is hardwood-smoked.
- Both statements are the companies' own claims, not independent test results.
Four checks on the product page tell you more than a brand's slogan:
- Weight. Look for ounces or pounds for every item.
- Cheese names. Check the type and strength, such as sharp or mild cheddar.
- Allergens. Read the allergen and gluten-free lines together.
- Terms. Look for substitution rules and best-by promises.
10. What Other Gift Companies Are Similar?
Shoppers who compare these two also ask about Harry & David, Wisconsin Cheeseman and Old Wisconsin. Each company's own history shows where it started:
- Harry & David says it launched its first catalog and began offering gift boxes of pears in 1934.
- Wisconsin Cheeseman dates its first mail-order flyer to 1946 and sells cheeses, sausages, chocolates and fruitcakes.
- Old Wisconsin began in 1947 as Thielmann's, a sausage shop in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, and sells summer sausage and snack sticks.
Harry & David began with fruit, Wisconsin Cheeseman with cheese and Old Wisconsin with sausage, so match the company to the food the person likes most.
11. Which One Should You Choose?
Match the brand to the situation, because neither one wins every time:
- You want a classic sausage-and-cheese gift. Either brand works, so choose by the product list: Hickory Farms for a choice of beef, turkey or Farmhouse sausage, and Swiss Colony for the Beef Log.
- You want something sweet in the same order. Swiss Colony lists bakery gifts and petits fours as their own category, in the same catalog as its sausages.
- The box has to arrive on a specific day. Hickory Farms lets you choose the delivery date at checkout; Swiss Colony gives delivery windows.
- You are sending to several households. Either site works, because both checkouts take several addresses.
- You want to see a store first. You can visit Hickory Farms' local stores in the holiday season.
- The recipient avoids sugar. Swiss Colony lists 20 sugar-free items, and Hickory Farms' site shows no sugar-free label.
- The recipient avoids gluten. Check the product page, because Hickory Farms labels its gluten-free items one by one and Swiss Colony's category listed one.
Once the box is open, you can serve it as a board with fruit, nuts and bread. The sides for a charcuterie board and the sides that go with summer sausage both work with either brand's gift.
Sources
- Swiss Colony, "Our Heritage"
- Swiss Colony blog, "Summer Sausage: A Wisconsin Tradition"
- Swiss Colony, Sausage and Cheese Bars product page, The Original Beef Log and homepage
- Swiss Colony, Sugar-Free & Gluten-Free category, Meats & Cheeses category and Delivery Included category
- Swiss Colony, shipping and processing information
- Hickory Farms, About Us, FAQs and refunds and replacements
- Hickory Farms, placing your order and gluten-free gifts
- Hickory Farms, Cheese & Sausage Lover's Gift Box and 7 Oz Signature Beef Summer Sausage
- Wisconsin Cheeseman, About, Old Wisconsin, Our History and Harry & David, Royal Riviera Pear History
- UW-Madison News, history of Swiss Colony and Colony Brands
- USDA FSIS, "Sausages and Food Safety"
- USDA FoodKeeper
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Swiss Colony Sell Hanukkah Candy?
Its homepage menu listed Christmas, Valentine's Day, Easter, Mother's Day, Father's Day and Thanksgiving under holidays on November 17, 2026, with no Hanukkah category.
Can You Freeze a Sausage and Cheese Gift?
Hickory Farms' FAQ says freezing its sausage and cheese may change the texture slightly. FoodKeeper lists hard cheese such as cheddar at 6 months in the freezer.

Food writer at GustoMeadow. Writes ingredient substitutes, food comparisons, taste guides and storage guides for home cooks.
Storage and food-safety numbers follow USDA, FDA and university extension guidance.









