The best substitutes for Cherry Tomatoes are Plum Style Tomatoes, Grape Tomatoes, Campari Tomatoes, Ripe Olives, and Sun-Dried Tomatoes.
Plum Style Tomatoes is the closest match - it has a similar flavor and works at a 1:1 ratio in most recipes.
For cooking, Grape Tomatoes also works well - adjust the amount to taste since it may be slightly stronger or milder.
Sometimes, you're all set to whip up that perfect dish, and bam, you realize you're out of cherry tomatoes.
Grapes might not be your first thought for a tomato substitute, but hear us out-they add that same burst of sweetness and a juicy pop.
These alternatives aren't just stand-ins; they can bring their own unique flair to your recipes.
From sun-dried to canned, different substitutes suit different dishes, offering flavors that can improve your meal in unexpected ways.
And who knows? You might find a new favorite ingredient along the way.
Sure, cherry tomatoes are great, but it's always exciting to shake things up in the kitchen.
By swapping them out, you're not just solving a problem-you're opening the door to new culinary experiments.
5 Flavorful Replacements for Cherry Tomatoes
Despite being a very popular vegetable, cherry tomatoes are often hard to find in the supermarket.
However, many substitutes can be used as an alternative, with each one being similar enough to still work well in the dish - including Bartending essentials: cherry liqueur substitutions for cocktail-minded cooks.
| Substitute | Key Characteristics | Proper Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| Plum Style Tomatoes | Larger, elongated shape with sweet flavor and less water content | Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of chopped plum style tomatoes |
| Grape Tomatoes | Small, oblong shape with sweet, juicy flavor and firm texture | Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of halved grape tomatoes |
| Campari Tomatoes | Sweet, tangy flavor, slightly larger than cherry tomatoes | Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of chopped Campari tomatoes |
| Ripe Olives | Savory, salty flavor with a soft texture and dark color | Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with ½ cup of halved ripe olives |
| Sun-Dried Tomatoes | Intense, concentrated flavor with a chewy texture | Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with ¼ cup of rehydrated sun-dried tomatoes |
Here is a closer look at each option:
1 - Plum Style Tomatoes
Plum-style tomatoes are smaller than a normal tomato and have a flattened shape.
They can be rather sweet, with a good balance of acidity.
Note that their skin may not be as tough as many other types of tomatoes, which makes them easier to cook with.
The skin of a plum tomato is significantly thinner than that of a normal-sized tomato, making them much easier to cook with.
These tomatoes are most commonly used in sauces pastes and can be used when canning or bottling fruits - see plum sauce substitute options for sauces when a different pantry staple is needed.
They have a unique flavor both in terms of initial and aftertaste, which you may or may not like.
However, most people find that they are generally quite sweet and an excellent replacement for cherry tomatoes in dishes where the latter doesn't fit.
- Key Characteristics: Plum style tomatoes are larger and more elongated than cherry tomatoes. They have a sweet flavor and contain less water, making them a suitable substitute.
- Proper Ratio: Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of chopped plum style tomatoes. Adjust the quantity based on your recipe's requirements.
2 - Grape Tomatoes
Grape tomatoes are very similar to cherry tomatoes in terms of their appearance, just much smaller.
They tend to be rounder than cherry tomatoes, which look like small grapes.
As their name suggests, grape tomatoes are produced after being harvested at the 'grape' stage when they are considered fully flavored and ripe - useful context if also exploring grape vinegar alternatives for cooking.
These can be very sweet or slightly sour, depending on how ripe they were picked.
This type of tomato is often used for salads or snacks due to its small size and sweeter than average flavor.
They tend to be very juicy, so you might need to cook them for less time than other substitutes.
- Key Characteristics: Grape tomatoes are small, oblong-shaped tomatoes with a sweet, juicy flavor and a firm texture. They closely resemble cherry tomatoes and can be used as a substitute in various dishes.
- Proper Ratio: Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of halved grape tomatoes. Adjust the quantity based on your recipe's needs.
3 - Campari Tomatoes
Campari tomatoes are very similar in their flavor and appearance to cherry tomatoes.
The main difference is that they are larger than the latter.
In addition, Campari tomatoes have slightly thicker skin, so you won't need to spend as much time preparing them before eating them.
This type of tomato originated from Italy and got its name from the Campari company.
When you eat a Campari tomato, its flavor is often mild, an acquired taste.
However, it has been described as being very sweet and tangy both simultaneously.
This substitute is great for salads and pasta dishes, as with other substitutes.
In addition, they are also great for cooking in stews or on the barbecue - and can stand in when stewed tomato substitutes for recipes are needed.
- Key Characteristics: Campari tomatoes are slightly larger than cherry tomatoes and have a sweet, tangy flavor. They can be used as a substitute while providing a similar taste profile.
- Proper Ratio: Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with 1 cup of chopped Campari tomatoes. Adjust the quantity based on your recipe's requirements.
4 - Ripe Olives
If you are looking for a substitute that will add a bit of flavor to your dish, then this might be the one for you.
Ripe olives have a salty and meaty flavor, resulting in dishes having a more rich or complex taste - similar to considerations when choosing Gaeta olive substitute ideas for briny flavor.
Note that ripe olives are generally very bitter, whereas cherry tomatoes tend to be quite sweet.
The bitterness of ripe olives can result in you adding a bit more sugar if the taste is too strong for your liking.
Ripe olives are very common and were first produced by the Greeks 2,000 years ago.
They also have a long history of being used as an edible food source, featuring in some of the earliest recipes.
- Key Characteristics: Ripe olives offer a savory, salty flavor with a soft texture. While they have a different taste compared to cherry tomatoes, they can provide a unique twist to recipes.
- Proper Ratio: Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with ½ cup of halved ripe olives. Adjust the quantity based on your preferred level of saltiness.
5 - Sun-Dried Tomatoes
Sun-dried tomatoes are a great substitute for cherry tomatoes, especially if they are on sale in your supermarket.
They tend to be much cheaper than other substitutes and can add many flavors when cooked properly.
Sun-dried tomatoes have a sweeter taste because they are dried and then added to dishes.
This means that you don't need to add as much sugar or salt as you normally would if you were using cherry tomatoes.
Sun-dried tomatoes work well in salads and pasta dishes, as with other substitutes.
However, they also work well on kebabs and baking cakes or brownies.
In addition, they work well in soups and stews if you add them early enough.
- Key Characteristics: Sun-dried tomatoes have an intense, concentrated flavor and a chewy texture. While the texture may differ from fresh cherry tomatoes, they can add depth and complexity to dishes.
- Proper Ratio: Replace 1 cup of cherry tomatoes with ¼ cup of rehydrated sun-dried tomatoes. Adjust the quantity based on your desired taste and texture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Plum Style Tomatoes is the best substitute for Cherry Tomatoes because it shares a similar flavor and texture. Use it at a 1:1 ratio in any recipe that calls for Cherry Tomatoes.
Yes. Plum Style Tomatoes and Grape Tomatoes work as direct replacements in most recipes.
Use the same quantity and adjust seasoning after tasting.
Usually not, but check moisture content. Wetter substitutes may need a slightly higher temperature or longer cook time to evaporate excess liquid and achieve the right texture.
Is the substitute appropriate for all dietary restrictions?
Check labels carefully.
Many substitutes introduce allergens or ingredients that conflict with specific diets - dairy, gluten, soy, or nuts may appear in processed alternatives.
For swapped tomato options that work in similar recipes, try diced tomatoes substitution ideas. For smoky roasted profiles, fire-roasted tomato replacement suggestions provides alternatives.